Verse 1:
                 F    Am
We ain't got the magic
              Csus4
Just a couple sparks
                 F          Am
We tried to justify all the dark
                             Csus4
With the little light in our hearts
                      F      Am
It's really somethin' tragic
                        C   C   C
We were doomed from the start
                   F
We took the little signs in the stars
   Am                         C   C   C
As something greater than they are

Pre-Chorus:
      Am
I'm a king, you're a queen
  G
I know we're royalty
    F
But that don't mean we're meant to be

Chorus:
-nc-
If the shoe don't fit, fit, fit, keep it off
-nc-
Darling, love like this, this, this don't belong
     F  Am  C                     G
Cinderella, I could never be your king
     F  Am  C                     G
Cinderella, we don't gotta try to be
                F                 Am
Somethin' we're not, this ain't a movie
             C                  G
We ain't the plot, we ain't the plot
     F  Am       C  C   C   C   C
Cinderella, Cinderella

Post-Chorus:
        F
-If the shoe don't fit, fit, fit-
Am
  -Keep it off, darling-
 C                         G
-Love like this, this, this-

Verse 2:
       F                  Am
Did we ever have it? -Hm?-
                 C
a feelin' in our hearts, yeah
                 F
But did we synthesize somethin'
             Am           C
Just to feel somethin' at all, all?

Pre-Chorus:
      Am
I'm a king, you're a queen
  G
I know we're royalty
    F                              C
But that don't mean we're meant to be

Chorus:
-nc-              C         C    -nc-
If the shoe don't fit, fit, fit, keep it off
-nc-               Am          G    -nc-
Darling, love like this, this, this don't belong
     F  Am  C                     G
Cinderella, I could never be your king
     F  Am  C                     G
Cinderella, we don't gotta try to be
                F                 Am
Somethin' we're not, this ain't a movie
             C                  G
We ain't the plot, we ain't the plot
     F  Am       C  C   C   C   C
Cinderella, Cinderella

Post-Chorus:
        F
-If the shoe don't fit, fit, fit-
Am
  -Keep it off, darling-
 C                         G
-Love like this, this, this-
        F
-If the shoe don't fit, fit, fit-
Am
  -Keep it off, darling-
 C                         C   C   C   C F
-Love like this, this, this-